Announcing The Anti-Certification

BRC audit: the practical Issue 9 preparation guide

A practical BRC audit and BRCGS Issue 9 readiness guide covering evidence registers, testing, traceability, grading, CAPA, and the audit-day workflow.

A BRC audit tests whether a food-safety system works on the production floor and leaves an evidence trail. Issue 9 auditors move from HACCP and food-safety culture to site conditions, labels, traceability, and laboratory results, then grade the non-conformities they find. Build readiness around the records, people, and decisions an auditor samples, then rehearse the day itself.

Testing is where many otherwise sound systems become hard to defend. At Light Labs, we pair our ISO 17025-accredited laboratory with a testing and compliance platform, keeping the method, result, limit, COA, and follow-up action connected. That evidence model is useful whether you are preparing for your first audit or maintaining certification.

What a BRC audit assesses

“BRC audit” usually means an independent certification audit against the BRCGS Global Standard Food Safety, Issue 9. BRCGS also publishes separate standards for packaging, storage and distribution, and agents and brokers; the sections and grading below apply to Food Safety Issue 9. BRCGS describes the food-safety standard as a framework for managing product safety, authenticity, legality, quality, and operational controls in food and ingredient manufacturing, processing, and packing. The audit is performed by a BRCGS-approved certification body, and certification is the decision that follows the audit and close-out of findings. The BRCGS standard page is the controlling reference for the requirements.

An auditor is looking for three connected kinds of evidence:

  1. Design: your policy, HACCP plan, specifications, procedures, and risk assessments define the control.
  2. Implementation: people follow the control, equipment works, and records are completed at the required frequency.
  3. Effectiveness: trends, verification, complaints, tests, and corrective actions show that the control works over time.

Use Issue 9 and its current position statements

Issue 9 is the published Food Safety standard while BRCGS develops Issue 10. The standard says that additions and amendments are issued as position statements, which are binding extensions of the requirements. The current F926 position statements, effective 10 August 2026, clarify unannounced-audit planning and the definition of an initial audit, and update clause 7.4.2 to include suitable protective footwear. Put the standard, position statements, and your internal revision log under one document-control owner.

The nine Issue 9 sections, translated into audit evidence

The standard has nine sections. A useful internal checklist follows the process flow and asks what an auditor must be able to see, hear, or retrieve.

Issue 9 sectionWhat the auditor is trying to establishEvidence to stage
1. Senior management commitment and continual improvementLeaders resource the system, set measurable objectives, review performance, and maintain a food-safety and quality culture plan.Signed policy, culture plan with measures, management-review minutes, quarterly objectives, previous-audit CAPA effectiveness.
2. The food safety plan, HACCPA competent, multidisciplinary team has identified hazards, set controls and critical limits, and kept the plan current after changes.Team competence, product descriptions, process-flow verification, hazard analysis, CCP validation and monitoring records.
3. Food safety and quality management systemThe system is controlled, retrievable, internally audited, and able to turn issues into preventive action.Document register, record-retention rules, internal-audit schedule and reports, supplier approvals, specifications, complaints, CAPA and recall records.
4. Site standardsThe building, utilities, hygiene, maintenance, pest, foreign-body, and segregation controls prevent contamination.Site map and traffic flows, inspections, cleaning verification, pest trends, maintenance and calibration, glass/brittle-plastic register, detector tests.
5. Product controlIngredients, allergens, authenticity, packaging, testing, shelf life, and release decisions protect safety, legality, and quality.Raw-material risk assessments, allergen validation, supplier COAs, product-testing plan and results, shelf-life studies, release authorisations.
6. Process controlWork instructions, process parameters, line checks, label controls, quantity controls, and deviations are followed in production.Current recipes and settings, start-up/changeover checks, CCP records, label reconciliation, coding checks, hold and disposition records.
7. PersonnelEveryone who can affect product safety is trained, competent, and following hygiene and protective-clothing rules.Role-based training matrix, competency assessments, induction records for temporary staff, hygiene observations, protective-clothing issue records.
8. Production risk zonesHigh-risk, high-care, and ambient high-care areas have the zoning, fabric, people flow, hygiene, and clothing controls their risk requires.Zone map, entry and exit controls, environmental monitoring, sanitation validation, footwear and clothing rules, zoning inspections.
9. Requirements for traded productsProducts bought for resale are approved, specified, tested, legally compliant, and traceable to the last manufacturer or packer.Supplier approval, buying specifications, independent product analysis, legal reviews, traded-product traceability and mass-balance records.

Twelve requirements are marked fundamental because a failure undermines the whole system: 1.1 senior management commitment, 2 HACCP, 3.4 internal audits, 3.5.1 supplier management, 3.7 corrective and preventive action, 3.9 traceability, 4.3 layout and segregation, 4.11 housekeeping and hygiene, 5.3 allergen management, 6.1 control of operations, 6.2 labelling and pack control, and 7.1 training. A major non-conformity against a fundamental statement of intent means no certification at an initial audit and withdrawal of certification at a subsequent audit. These requirements are listed in the Issue 9 standard requirements.

Build an evidence system that survives sampling

BRCGS audits by sampling. Make each sample easy to follow with an evidence register containing:

  • clause and risk being controlled
  • named process owner and deputy
  • current procedure number and revision
  • required record, frequency, and retention period
  • latest completed example and one older example
  • verification or trend output
  • open issues, root cause, owner, due date, and effectiveness evidence

Issue 9 requires records to be retained for at least the product shelf life plus 12 months. It also requires an internal-audit programme with at least four different audit dates spread through the year, with every activity in the food-safety and quality system covered at least annually. Open-product areas need a separate hygiene and fabrication inspection programme at least monthly. Those frequencies belong in the register, rather than in a last-minute audit calendar.

Use a simple retrieval test: give a colleague a clause, SKU, lot, date, or deviation and time how long it takes to reach the source record, related result, and closure evidence. Slow retrieval usually signals a broken ownership or revision link. Fix the workflow, then repeat the exercise across shifts and co-manufacturers.

Where laboratory evidence changes the outcome

Issue 9 clause 5.6 requires a scheduled, risk-based programme for microbiological, chemical, physical, and organoleptic testing. The programme documents methods, sample collection and delivery, frequency, and specified limits. Results are reviewed for trends, unsatisfactory results trigger prompt action, and measurement uncertainty is considered where applicable. Pathogen testing is subcontracted to an external laboratory or completed in a fully segregated internal facility. Critical analyses must use a recognised accredited laboratory or operate to ISO/IEC 17025 principles, including proficiency testing where applicable.

That requirement turns a COA folder into a controlled testing system. For each product or raw material, keep one chain of evidence:

  1. risk assessment and reason for each analyte or organism
  2. approved method, matrix, detection limit, and laboratory accreditation status
  3. sample identity, lot, collection date, sampler, and chain of custody
  4. result with units, uncertainty where relevant, and the applicable specification or action limit
  5. technical review, release or hold decision, and trend analysis
  6. deviation, root cause, corrective action, and re-test where a limit is exceeded

Supplier paperwork is evidence of what a supplier reported. It is not independent confirmation. For traded products, clause 9.4.2 requires periodic independent product analysis when conformity is supported by a supplier certificate or analysis. The same risk logic belongs in raw-material approval: Issue 9 allows sampling and testing, visual inspection, consignment-specific COAs, or certificates of conformance, with the method and frequency defined by the risk assessment.

Our lab runs validated LC-MS/MS, ICP-MS, HPLC, and GC-MS methods for food and supplement matrices. Our platform stores test orders, results, COAs, product-level action limits, and re-test notifications together, so a reviewer can move from a failed result to the decision and the preventive action without hunting through email.

Plan the BRC audit from scope to certificate

1. Set the scope before building the checklist

Agree the products, processes, packaging formats, traded products, outsourced steps, and applicable production zones with the certification body. Use a body listed in the BRCGS Directory and accepted by your customers. A narrow or ambiguous scope creates findings when the auditor sees a process that the certificate does not describe.

2. Send a useful pre-audit pack

The certification body will typically request a company overview, HACCP summary and CCPs, process-flow diagram, site plan, organisation chart, products in scope, special handling requirements, building description, shift patterns, production schedules, outsourced processes, recalls, quality issues, complaints, testing, traceability, and significant changes. Send controlled versions early so the auditor can plan the sampling.

3. Allow the right amount of time

The BRCGS calculator sets a typical audit at two to three days, generally eight to nine hours per day and never more than ten. It bases the duration on full-time-equivalent employees on the main shift, facility size including on-site storage, and the number of HACCP plans. High-risk or high-care areas, traded products, additional modules, and extra HACCP plans add time. Approximately half the audit is spent in production and site facilities, interviewing staff, observing processes, and reviewing records where the work happens. Use the Issue 9 audit-duration calculator when agreeing the plan.

4. Rehearse the actual audit sequence

An Issue 9 audit moves through:

  1. opening meeting and scope confirmation
  2. production, storage, and site inspection
  3. discussions with operators, supervisors, and managers
  4. document review of HACCP and the management system
  5. vertical audit, traceability challenge, and mass balance
  6. verification of CCPs and other product-safety controls
  7. label review and production-facility inspection records
  8. auditor review of findings and closing meeting

The most senior operations manager, or a nominated deputy, attends the opening and closing meetings. Keep a technical lead, production lead, maintenance or engineering contact, laboratory or testing owner, and document runner available. Give each person a defined area and a backup. Answers should describe the work as it is performed, identify the procedure, and produce the record that proves it.

5. Prepare for announced and unannounced audits

Announced audits are scheduled in advance. Under the announced programme, at least one audit in every three-year cycle is unannounced. The certification body tells the site the year, not the date, and the unannounced audit takes place during normal operation within the final four months of the audit cycle. A blended announced audit can review documented systems remotely before an on-site visit, subject to a certification-body risk assessment. Treat every production shift as the real audit: keep records current, make deputies competent, and keep the audit room and digital evidence available without special staging.

Run a traceability challenge that proves genealogy

Traceability is a fundamental requirement. The BRCGS traceability guideline describes the same end-to-end link from original material to customer. Issue 9 expects a test across product groups, from raw-material and primary-packaging suppliers through processing and dispatch, and in reverse. The test includes a quantity check or mass balance, happens at least annually, and should be achievable within four hours. Rework and label versions belong in the same genealogy.

A practical run sheet looks like this:

Elapsed timeActivityOutput
0–30 minutesSelect a finished lot and lock the starting quantity.Finished-goods record, label and dispatch list.
30–90 minutesPull every ingredient, packaging, and rework lot used.Receiving, COA, batch-sheet and inventory links.
90–150 minutesReconcile input quantities to yield, waste, samples, and stock.Signed mass-balance calculation and variance explanation.
150–210 minutesTrace forward to customers, warehouses, or holds.Distribution list and quantity by destination.
210–240 minutesReview gaps, record the result, and assign CAPA.Timed test report, root cause, action owner and due date.

A COA proves a test result. It does not prove where a lot went. Keep the COA linked to the receiving record, batch record, finished-goods code, and distribution record so an auditor can follow both safety evidence and product movement.

Understand findings, grades, and the 28-day response window

BRCGS classifies findings as:

  • Critical: a critical failure involving a food-safety or legal issue.
  • Major: a substantial failure against a statement of intent or clause, or objective evidence that creates significant doubt about product conformity.
  • Minor: a clause is not fully met, while product conformity is not in doubt.

A critical finding, a major finding against a fundamental statement of intent, or findings beyond the grading limits prevents certification. No certificate is issued until major and minor findings are corrected, and each finding also needs a root-cause analysis and preventive-action plan.

For orientation, when there are no major or critical findings, the minor-only ranges in the Issue 9 grading criteria are:

Announced gradeUnannounced gradeMinor findingsTypical next audit
AAAA+0–512 months
AA+6–1012 months
BB+11–1612 months
CC+17–246 months
DD+25–306 months

Major findings change those ranges. With one major, the published limits are up to 10 minors for B, 11–16 for C, and 17–24 for D. With two majors, C permits up to 10 minors and D up to 16. Higher combinations, any critical finding, or a major against a fundamental requirement are uncertificated outcomes. C audits with two majors and all D audits require a revisit or remote assessment within 28 calendar days.

Submit objective evidence of correction, root cause, and preventive action within 28 calendar days. The certification body has 14 days to review the evidence, and the certification decision and certificate are due within 42 days of the audit. The audit report is uploaded to the BRCGS Directory within 49 days. Evidence can include revised procedures, completed records, photographs, invoices, a remote assessment, or a further site visit. Show that the new control is operating, rather than only promising to introduce it.

FAQ

Is a BRC audit the same as BRCGS certification?

No. The audit is the independent assessment. Certification is the certification body’s decision after it reviews findings, corrective action, root cause, and preventive action.

How long does a BRC audit take?

Most audits take two to three days on site. Employee count, facility size, HACCP-plan count, production complexity, risk zones, traded products, and additional modules can extend the duration.

How often is a BRC audit required?

Successful sites are generally audited on a six- or 12-month cycle, depending on grade and findings. Sites in the announced programme also receive at least one unannounced audit every three years.

Can a site use an internal laboratory?

Yes, if it is fully segregated and controlled to prevent product contamination. Critical analyses need a recognised laboratory accreditation or operation to ISO/IEC 17025 principles, with proficiency testing where applicable. Many sites subcontract pathogen testing.

What happens after a major non-conformity?

Contain affected product where needed, correct the immediate issue, identify the system root cause, and submit objective evidence plus a preventive-action plan within 28 days. A major against a fundamental requirement or a critical finding means the site must undergo a full re-audit before certification can be considered.

Make testing evidence easy to retrieve

A BRC audit is easier to run when your laboratory results, action limits, COAs, supplier evidence, and CAPA history share one controlled trail. We can map your risk-based testing programme to our ISO 17025-accredited lab and keep the resulting evidence searchable by SKU, lot, method, and status. Talk with Light Labs about your testing workflow.

Final takeaway

Prepare for a BRC audit as a live operating system. Keep the 12 fundamentals working every day, connect each test to a documented risk and decision, rehearse a four-hour traceability and mass-balance challenge, and give corrective actions owners, evidence, and effectiveness checks. That is how a certificate reflects control customers can trust.

Sources6 sources
  1. Global Standard Food Safety (Issue 9) - BRCGS
  2. Behind the scenes of Food Safety Issue 10 - BRCGS
  3. F926: Position Statements for Issue 9 - BRCGS
  4. Food Safety Help and Guidance - BRCGS
  5. BRCGS Certification Body Search - BRCGS Directory
  6. Best Practice Guideline - Traceability - BRCGS
Ready to modernize your testing?

Whether you’re a brand or a co-manufacturer, Light Labs helps you move faster, stay compliant, and eliminate testing bottlenecks — all from a modern, shared platform.

Modern lab testing for cleaner, safer products.

Built in Austin, Texas.